My team, Aston Villa, would probably be R-Truth. Will never win anything, but came close a few years back. Goes through stages of being entertaining, then shit.
John Cena is easily Man United - been at the top for what feels like forever, incredibly divisive and hated by a lot of people, still sells millions of shirts though.
Sheamus is Man City - no one really cared about them before about 2008/2009, when they suddenly appeared on the scene and started winning things. Rarely lose.
Until last season, Wigan were JTG - consistently shit but somehow always hung around.
Portsmouth are Evan Bourne - they were quite good a few years ago, but no one knows where they are now.
Continue!