Okay, I'm really late to the party here. But I said I'd read this show, and I'm a man of my word. Now it's time to get some comments up in this bitch!!
The Format:I have to say that the little images and logos and different colours of text really help to make things pop a little bit more. It breaks up the wall of text and makes everything seem a little easier to digest. So kudos on that.
On a more negative note, why do you use one commentator's first name and the other commentator's surname? It's a shallow thing, but it bugs me.
Phoenix Fray Battle Royale:This one was a little hard to keep track of at times, particularly for someone who wasn't familiar with all the characters. It was confusing at the start because it was announced as a six person match but only five people entered. Ace randomly appeared a little later, but I was wondering what the fuck was happening there for a minute. That's the disadvantage of writing matches like this; those kinds of things can get lost in the shuffle.
I didn't know the characters here that well, but I have to say I enjoyed them all. I did get mixed signals from Sears - I might be missing substantial elements of his character due to not having read much stuff from him in the past, but I didn't think Deftones seemed to fit his character. Other than that, I liked him. My favourites though were Bishop & Reece. Both their characters jumped off the screen for me. Bishop just seemed like a mean ass kicking type, while Reece was a little bit like a more likable face version of Maverick. If those two are going to be in a feud soon, that should be exciting.
The action here was good too. I liked the double elimination and some of the interferences. Showing Bishop's elimination via replay was an interesting choice, and I think it actually worked. Decisions like that would regularly bother me but it seemed to be done for the right reasons and in the right way. It kept Bishop looking strong as it showed how unexpected it was for him to be eliminated at that particular moment. It made Reece look cool too though. This was a fun way to open the show.
A Fair Fight:I liked this segment. It told me a lot about both characters and their relationship. Not sure what the context for it is exactly - whether there's been underlying tension between the two or anything like that. But I got the impression that it was a regular mentor/student relationship where the student is starting to become more confident and assert himself more because he's getting good enough to do so. It makes sense for anyone that Omega is paired with to be the reasonable one also.
Nice character development here.
Amos Hess vs Some Bitch Who Can't Hang With Our Savior:I love Hess's entrance. The laughing is great. More people should do something like that - really making an impact and setting the character apart right from the moment he walks out. Plus I can imagine that when Hess appears unexpectedly on the weekly shows, it works much better than with other characters. It's much cooler to have someone getting cut-off suddenly by "HAHAHAHAHAHAHA" than to just write that someone's music plays and he walks out.
It was a super effective little match too. Hess could have been doing something more productive on the show probably, but maybe everyone else was just too busy with other stuff. That being said, I thought this was one of the highlights of the entire show. Simple but effective. Hess's cast was creepy, his unmasking his opponent followed by the Field Plow was a great visual. I have to commend ShaneOfan for getting the basics so right - having possibly the most memorable finisher and the most memorable entrance in the fed makes a big difference for a character.
The Zanetti Family:This was an odd one for me. It seemed like it was supposed to be very serious, but it came off pretty cheesy. I might be misreading that. I thought the idea of two guys coming in with the intention of wiping out various tag teams was interesting. Definitely makes them seem like threats right out of the gate. If the tag teams are being portrayed as hits though, does that mean someone's pulling their strings. Who is it that wants these teams out of the way? This piqued my curiosity, even if I thought the explosion was a bit weird.
Gryphon Richard vs Andrew Logan:Turns out that Gryphon Richard has a great entrance too. And that theme really seems to go with his character. I approve of this. A good entrance makes a big difference to me. And of course, Logan's entrance is distinct too with the cool little graphic. This was an interesting booking decision putting these two together. It's outside the box, but it really works. Instead of putting Logan against someone who had a history with him, you put him against someone new - and a character that seems generally decent and trusting. That's the perfect foil for a character who's trying to prove that he's changed his ways.
This was an enjoyable match; very tight and professional and it told an interesting story. I liked that the match was clean fought and that there was such a focus on strategy - what the bigger man and smaller man should be doing to play to their strengths, how Gryphon's inexperience effected his performance. I thought the way Logan's full heel turn was teased was cleverly done for the most part, although Cage's reasoning for why Logan picked up the chair in the first place was a bit absurd, which made it look like Logan really was just being an evil jerk. I think it would have left things more open to interpretation if Logan had played it up (after Omega came out), that he was getting the chair so that the referee could sit down and recuperate. I think that would have been more on point. That's a small detail though. On the whole, I really enjoyed the match.
God's Favourite Tag Team:This was a really cool promo. Just a good way of hyping up the match. Melissa Chambers comes off confident and sassy as ever, and seems to have transitioned well to her face role. All of the in-character talk about never wearing the same outfit twice and blending together was very effective too. Neo Runway Chic and Melissa Chambers never fail to stand out from the other teams.
The Disciples vs Neo Runway Chic:It's cool that Hess has his own stable now. He definitely seems worthy of the honour, and it's a different kind of stable to any we had going in the WCSF. Wow, Knight has really had a hell of a career, hasn't he?
He's wrestled in all kinds of company's and under all sorts of gimmicks. Is edgecution still around or is someone else writing him these days?
I like that Adrian Dale is creating problems for his team. Having two separate personalities within one tag team is important and Daz has managed to pull it off while still making his team fit together, which takes talent. I enjoyed the style of wrestling on display in this match. I thought Barry's offense was cool. He's probably someone who went under the radar for a long time, but he seems to have come a long way in PCW. It feels like this fed has a lot more ass kicking, brawling types than WCSF had, which is no bad thing.
The match was impressive. I liked that the strategy of picking on one member of the team ultimately backfired when the fresh man got in. Tag team booking 101 there. The pace of the match really worked too, starting slow but gradually accelerating. When a match is Daz length, you need the pacing to be done well to keep you immersed and that worked here perfectly.
Valentino vs Zaid: I'm not particularly familiar with either of these characters, but for all that, the writers did a good job of showcasing them in this match. I definitely got an idea that they had a bad history and the tension really did come across. Zaid seemed like the biggest shit of a heel you're likely to find, taking every cheap shot. It felt like he knew for the whole match that he was about to get what he deserved and he was doing anything he could to try and put off the inevitable. It was a cool story.
I did think some of the commentary went a bit over the top at points in the match, but at least the action felt within the bounds of what can be done in matches like this. A few less exclamation marks would have been fine though.
Either way, I liked this one. I'm not sure who wrote it, but nicely done.
Assassin's Creed:I wasn't a massive fan of the promo here, I thought it was a little too lacking in focus and that the sentence structure was a bit choppy. I did like how it brought in a little bit of history between the two and that it tried to highlight Miller as being a more dangerous competitor now. Though I always find it a little unnatural how much he has changed since WCSF.
Miller v Daz:Just let me mark out about Daz's entrance for a second. Okay now I'm done. I wasn't a fan of Miller becoming a brand new character while still being the same guy ... I thought that was weird. But with that being said, the new Miller makes for an interesting opponent for Daz in a way that the old one wouldn't have. And I enjoyed that this was being portrayed as the biggest match of his career. That felt organic.
Daz playing loose with the rules was a nice differentiation from his usual behaviour and it made the feud feel more personal instantly. Daz is most known for his submission wrestling and technical prowess, but it can't be all O'Connor rolls in the midst of a heated feud and Daz is smart enough to know that. I liked how violent this match was without actually being no disqualification. There was a lot of great sequences of just strikes. And the descriptions helped too - like headbutting someone and describing the swelling on the victim's eyebrow. It's still legal, but now it sounds vicious.
I'm not sure I bought the part where Miller goaded Daz into giving him the DQ victory. Miller maybe seemed crazy enough to take a beating for the win, but I just couldn't imagine a scenario where Daz actually snapped and did it. Lots of cheeky near falls as this match wears on with both men looking like gold. It really started to feel like a long, grueling match that was taking everything out of both men. Not surprised to see Miller get the win - it was a good move to help elevate the character. But it's cool that the commentators really played up the upset. Good match here.
Munging Time:The Deadliest Viper is in the house!!
This was a cool little promo to help reestablish the character. I do have the same problem as with Miller in that it seems like a whole new character under the same name. But we've been through that before with Drake Bernard so that practically is part of his character by now.
Good to see him back in the mix.
Magnum Opus:If I was to write one more big match, I'd want it to be with Tim. For three reasons. First of all, I've never written a proper program with Tim. Second of all, Maverick has unfinished business with the Logans. And third of all, Magnum is the fucking tits. I like this guy. He's got attitude. I think this new belt seems like a good idea too. It's got an identity to it and will help get Magnum over in the long run.
It opens up a lot of cool potential matches too. If I was writing, I'd want Mav v Magnum in a knockout match. But better still, it looks like we're getting Omega vs Magnum. And that's just a perfect fit for the inaugural Lone Star championship match if that's the way this is going. Nice pairing here, it's bound to produce quality results.
Just Like Old Times:Fucking mothertrucking Johnny fucking DEVINE! Mark out moment there, that was a cool little interaction. Foster's going on to become the fourth Mafia member to become a world champion.
Main Event: Love the inclusion of the tale of the tape, it just makes things feel more official. The writers did a great job in following this up too. The slow introductions and the effort to make it feel like there was a big fight atmosphere ... all of that added a star to this match before it even began. It just puts you in the mood for an epic showdown. And again the slow start to the match with the grappling just helped to keep that buzz in the air before things really exploded.
Foster nursing his injuries during the match was a nice touch, as it let him be the aggressor but also held him back. When he was pushing himself further than his body was willing to go, it really showed how much he wanted the victory. The babyface in peril act was worked nicely in general, with Kaiser coming up with something to cut the challenger down every time he started building momentum.
Kaiser came off an evil bastard in this one, and Foster was the perfect resilient babyface, taking everything the heel could throw at him. The match had some great false finishes that almost had me jumping out of my seat, and I liked how Foster just soldiered on while Kaiser threw tantrums and panicked every time he failed to score the pinfall. The Devine Valley Driver would have been a great way to end it. The Top rope Kaiser bomb sounded scary. And the submission counter to the Kaiser bomb was a great visual. Masterful end to the match. Best match I've read in a long time, guys. Ye knocked it out of the park.